Public Safety Committee
Rochester Hills
1000 Rochester Hills |
Drive |
Rochester Hills, MI 48309 |
Home Page: |
www.rochesterhills.org |
Minutes
Adam Alleman, Bryan Barnett, Ron Crowell, Louis Eble, Gary Elliot, Andy LeBlanc, Linda |
Raschke, Gerald Robbins, Andrew Roscoe, Bob Smith |
7:30 PM
1000 Rochester Hills Drive
Monday, June 6, 2005
CALL TO ORDER
Chairperson Raschke called the Public Safety Committee meeting to order at 7:50 p.m.
ROLL CALL
Linda Raschke, Louis Eble and Gary Elliott
Present:
Bryan Barnett and Gerald Robbins
Absent:
Non-Voting Members Present: Ron Crowell, Robert Smith, and Andy LeBlanc. |
Non-Voting Members Absent: Adam Alleman, Andy LeBlanc and Andrew Roscoe. |
Others Present: Rochester Hills Fire Department: Bill Cooke, Fire Inspector and Mark |
Neuville, Suppression Captain |
Committee Member Roscoe provided previous notice he would be unable to attend and |
asked to be excused. |
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2005-0179
Regular Meeting - February 7, 2005
DRAFT Minutes.pdf; Resolution.pdf
A motion was made by Eble, seconded by Elliott, that this matter be Approved. |
Resolved that the Public Safety Committee hereby approves the Minutes of the |
Regular Meeting of February 7, 2005 as presented. |
The motion carried by the following vote: |
Aye:
Raschke, Eble and Elliott
Absent:
Barnett and Robbins
2005-0321
Regular Meeting - March 14, 2005
DRAFT Minutes.pdf; Resolution.pdf
A motion was made by Elliott, seconded by Eble, that this matter be Approved. |
Resolved that the Public Safety Committee hereby approves the Minutes of the |
Regular Meeting of March 14, 2005 as presented. |
The motion carried by the following vote: |
Aye:
Raschke, Eble and Elliott
Absent:
Barnett and Robbins
COMMUNICATIONS
2005-0396
Definitions for Emergency Medical Dispatch
Definition sheet.pdf
The Committee reviewed the basic definitions for Emergency Medical Dispatch.
Received and Filed
2005-0340
Discuss Use of Tax Increment Financing (TIF) to Fund Police & Fire Service - |
Memo from Dan Casey, Planning & Development Dept. |
022205 Memo Casey re TIF.pdf
The consensus of the Committee was to postpone this topic until the July Public Safety |
Committee meeting. |
Postponed
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
2005-0110
Monthly Report - Fire Chief
020705 Memo Crowell.pdf
Chief Crowell gave a brief update that included the following: |
* The Rochester Hills Fire Department (RHFD) took delivery last month of a tanker, an |
engine and three (3) administrative vehicles that replaced ailing and damaged vehicles. |
* The RHFD is going to use, on a test-basis, two (2) motorcycles from the City of |
Pontiac Fire Department to determine if they are an effective way to assist with medical |
incidents that may occur during the Festival of the Hills due to traffic congestion. |
* The switch from using gas cards to the fuel station at the Department of Public Safety |
(DPS) Building will likely be completed this month and should save an estimated $1,000 |
per month in fuel costs. |
Discussed
2005-0170
Discuss Survey to Municipal Fire Departments
Compiled Survey Responses.pdf; Survey List - Municipal Fire Depts.pdf; |
Response letter to Fire Chiefs.pdf; Auburn Hills FD Survey.pdf; Brandon |
Twp FD Survey.pdf; Chesterfield Twp FD Survey.pdf; Farmington Hills FD |
Survey.pdf; Independence Twp FD Survey.pd |
The consensus of the Committee was to postpone this topic until the July Public Safety |
Committee meeting. |
Postponed
2004-0028
Discussion of Fire Department's Five-Year Plan (2000) and Fire Response |
Time |
011204 Req 5 Yr Plan & CEMS.pdf; 020204 CEMS Response Times & |
False Alarm Info.pdf; 2004 Bravo Staffing Statistics.pdf |
The Committee briefly discussed a new Five Year Plan and noted the following: |
* The criteria of first Five Year Plan (2000) has been met. |
* The Committee will be looking into a new Five Year Plan with the input from the |
Rochester Hills Fire Department (RHFD). |
* Although the previous millage attempts have failed, the Committee has worked very |
hard to educate the public regarding public safety needs. |
* The general city population may not know that the RHFD is a "combined Fire |
Department" consisting full-time and paid-on-call personnel. |
* In additional to millage funding, there may be other resources such as grants and user |
fees to help offset service costs. |
Discussed
2004-0032
Discussion of False Alarm Ordinance
Agenda Summary.pdf; 0032 Referral Notice.pdf; Sterling Heights False |
Alarm Info.pdf; False Alarm info.pdf; 033104 Agenda Summary.pdf; |
020204 PS Minutes.pdf; 032604 Master Report.pdf; 040204 Memo Capt. |
Smith.pdf; 091405 Resolution.pdf; 0032 Resolution.pdf |
The Committee briefly discussed the False Alarm ordinance and made the following |
points: |
* At the April Public Safety Committee meeting, Mayor Somerville indicated her support |
of a False Alarm ordinance that can be upheld. |
* In order to achieve maximum results, it is very important to follow a proven, successful |
model. |
* The City of Sterling Heights has recently implemented a False Alarm Ordinance. |
Discussed
2005-0233
Police Funding
Agenda Summary.pdf; Supplemental Memo Jenuwine dtd 2-17-06.pdf; |
Supplemental Memo Jenuwine dtd 2-13-06.pdf; Supplemental Memo |
Jenuwine dtd 5-09-05.pdf; Memo Jenuwine dtd 3-31-05.pdf; 2005 - OCSD |
Millage Analysis.pdf; 2005 - OCSD Millage Analysis R&E.pdf |
The consensus of the Committee was to postpone this topic until the July Public Safety |
Committee meeting. |
Postponed
NEW BUSINESS
2005-0339
Discuss Future Fire Department Positions
Draft Resolution of Support.pdf
Chief Crowell discussed the current agreement with the Oakland County Medical |
Control Authority (OCMCA) and how it relates to the current operations of the RHFD. |
The following points were made: |
* In 2004, the OCMCA identified the RHFD as an "Interim Advance Life Support |
Agency" through 2007. |
* An Interim Agency can run two (2) two-man Advance Life Support (ALS) units and one |
(1) one-man ALS unit. |
* Under the Agreement, RHFD has to show progression toward being a complete ALS |
provider by eventually having two (2) paramedics on each unit which will require the City |
to hire three (3) paramedics for Fiscal Year 2006 and three (3) paramedics for Fiscal |
Year 2007 so that all ALS units will respond with a minimum of two (2) men at all times. |
Chief Crowell also read the following excerpt from the OCMCA agreement, "... the |
community will submit a letter from the local governing body acknowledging its intent to |
achieve the Oakland County ALS standard of a minimum of two (2) paramedics within |
three (3) years. A one year extension will be considered by the OCMCA provided the |
community can demonstrate substantial progress towards compliance and a plan to |
comply with twelve (12) months". |
Based on the Agreement, the City has 2006 and 2007 to comply. If the City hires three |
(3) paramedics in 2006, but cannot hire three (3) in 2007 due to financial constraints, |
then the City could apply for a one (1) year extension to the Agreement. However, the |
City would be required to hire three (3) paramedics for Fiscal Year 2008. |
The Committee consensus was to discuss this again at the July Public Safety |
Committee meeting. |
Discussed
YOUTH COMMENTS
None were presented.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
2005-0435
Discussion of Emergency Preparedness
Chairperson Raschke introduced Ms. Karen Bickle, 735 Sandstone, who came before |
the Committee to discuss her concern about the Consumers Power gas leak that |
occurred in May on Squirrel and Dutton Roads. |
Ms. Bickle stated that her concern was what could have been done differently to notify |
the residents of the situation so they could have stayed off the 911 emergency lines in |
case another emergency was happening at the same time. |
The Committee discussed the emergency situation and made the following points: |
* In this case, the RHFD and the Sheriff's Department could not put themselves in a |
position to determine what area is safe or unsafe until Consumers Power made the |
determination. This case was also unique because it encompassed four (4) municipal |
jurisdictions. |
* Had this emergency lasted longer than it did, there would have been formal updates |
on the TV and radio stations. |
* When an emergency of a large magnitude occurs, there are ten (10) things that |
Sheriff Commanders have to do simultaneously as part of an "instant command" |
procedure in order to make an assessment. It takes time to determine which Fire Chief |
is in charge [by law], the type of emergency, the solutions needed and set up a media |
center for updates to the community. |
* Much of the evacuation was self-initiated due to residents speaking with media and |
the media relaying incorrect information to the public. |
* This is the first time since Oakland County went into an enhanced 911 program where |
the 911 lines were all busy at the same time. |
* When 911 lines are busy, the next best method for emergency notification is tuning to |
TV Channels 2, 4 or 7 and/or tuning to radio station WJR. |
* It is important for every subdivision or complex to have an active association group in |
order to help each other in an emergency. It is equally important for each household to |
have flashlights, transistor radios and supplies on hand in order to take care of |
themselves for the first day or two during a critical emergency. |
* From an emergency standpoint, Chief Crowell and Capt. Smith were very satisfied |
with the way in which the gas leak was handled. |
* Chief Crowell and Capt. Smith are in the process of re-examining a local radio system |
that may be used to broadcast emergency update information such as, "...there is an |
emergency, however, we have no information at this time, please do not call 911, and |
stay tuned to this station for further updates..." or something to that affect. |
The Committee thanked Ms. Bickle for her valid input. |
Discussed
2005-0437
Referral from Public Safety Committee re: Bike Path Stop Signs
Referral to LAC.pdf
Chairperson Raschke introduced Mr. Greg Formanczyk, 329 Powderhorn Court, who |
came before the Committee to discuss a safety concern regarding the need for signage |
on City bike paths to alert pedestrians, cyclists and joggers to stop or yield before |
crossing intersections. This concern was previously discussed at two (2) Public Safety |
Committee Meetings in 2004. |
The Committee briefly discussed different methods of signage. It was the concensus of |
the Committee to refer this matter to the Leisure Activities Committee for review |
because bike paths are funded by a millage under Parks & Forestry. |
Approved and Referred to the Leisure Activities Committee
NEXT MEETING DATE
Monday, July 11, 2005 - 7:30 p.m.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to discuss, Chairperson Raschke adjourned the |
meeting at 9:20 p.m. |
Minutes were prepared by Denise Mertz. |
Minutes were approved as presented at the November 14, 2005 Rescheduled Public |
Safety Committee Meeting. |