Administration and Information |
Services Committee |
Rochester Hills
1000 Rochester Hills |
Drive |
Rochester Hills, MI 48309 |
Home Page: |
www.rochesterhills.org |
Minutes
John L. Dalton, April Feng, Bob Grace, Melinda Hill, Barbara Holder, Stephen Kirksey, |
Pam Lee, Jane Leslie, Jennifer Stein, Gerard Verschueren |
4:00 PM
1000 Rochester Hills Drive
Tuesday, May 17, 2005
CALL TO ORDER
Chairperson Holder called the Administration & Information Services Committee meeting |
to order at 4:02 PM. |
ROLL CALL
Melinda Hill, John Dalton, Barbara Holder and Stephen Kirksey
Present:
Gerard Verschueren
Absent:
Non-Voting Members Present: Bob Grace, Pam Lee, Jane Leslie, April Feng and |
Jennifer Stein |
Non-Voting Members Absent: None |
Others Present: Jean Farris, Supervisor, Purchasing; Kevin Krajewski, Deputy Director, |
MIS; Roger Moore, Professional Surveyor, DPS; Susan Koliba-Galeckza, City Council |
Liaison; Margaret Strate, Administrative Secretary; and Mark Witte, CDV Youth |
Representative |
Committee Member Verschueren provided previous notice he would be unable to attend |
and asked to be excused. |
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
None were presented.
NEW BUSINESS
Per the request from the Youth Representatives, Chairperson Holder moved the order of |
business to discuss file 2005-0292 of NEW BUSINESS. |
2005-0292
Referral of Youth Council Bylaws for Adoption by City Council
Agenda Summary.pdf; RHCYC Bylaws 051705.pdf; Strate Memo |
041305.pdf; Bylaws Youth Draft.pdf; 0292 Resolution.pdf |
The Committee discussed the recommended changes for the second draft of the Youth |
Council Bylaws and came to the following consensus: |
* Article II, Section 2.: Appointment of Youth Representatives - keep the same verbiage |
as the first draft. |
* Article III, Section 3.: Annual Projects - change verbiage to the second draft. |
* Article IV, Section 1c.: Application and Selection Process - change verbiage to the |
second draft and create an "incumbent application". |
* Article V, Section 6: Procedure for Election - change verbiage to the second draft. |
* Article VI, Meetings: Change verbiage to second draft. |
* Article VIII, Quorum and Voting: Change verbiage to second draft. |
* The formatting should remain the same as other committee bylaws maintained by the |
Clerk's Department. |
* While the current objective to setting up the Youth Council is to "mirror" the City |
Council, the Youth Council can bring changes back to the AIS Committee as needed. |
The Committee agreed to move this item forward to City Council for recommended |
approval. |
Recommended for Approval to the City Council Regular Meeting
Enactment No: RES0184-2005 |
COMMUNICATIONS
Mr. Bob Grace, Director of MIS, informed the Committee that the following three (3) files |
represent different projects that are in the MIS budget, but they are not necessarily all |
MIS projects, meaning that MIS is working with other departments to help bring these |
projects forward. |
2005-0403
Discussion of 2005 Network Upgrade
Network Upgrade Project Info.pdf
Mr. Kevin Krajewski, Deputy Director of MIS, gave an update on the network upgrade |
that included the following: |
* The existing network was installed approximately January 2001. It is currently at four |
and one-half (4 1/2) years old; the normal replacement time is approximately three (3) |
years. |
* Plante Moran was awarded a contract to perform an analysis and design in October |
2004. The Request For Proposal (RFP) was issued in April with bid responses due |
May, 18; hopefully the bids will come in under the budgeted amount of $444,850. |
* The RFP included networking upgrades to the DPS Facility and Fire Station 1, |
upgrades to hardware and software storage, system integrations, private networking |
capabilities for remote users and sites, firewalling issues, antiviral traffic scanning, |
automating "patch management" on workstations, and an email achiving system. |
Discussed
2005-0363
Discussion of Large Format Digital Storage and Retrieval System
Large Digital Format info.pdf; Network upgrade project info.pdf; Asset |
Management CIP info.pdf |
An Adminstrative team comprised of Ms. Jean Farris, Procurement Supervisor, Mr. |
Kevin Krajewski, Deputy Director of MIS and Mr. Roger Moore, Professional Surveyor |
for the City, presented an update of the Large Format Digital Storage and Retrieval |
System (LFDSRS) including a consultant to assist the City in developing an RFP for an |
actual system. A vendor has been selected and negotiations have been done to reduce |
costs down approximately 8% to 10%. |
The question remains as to whether it should move forward to Council for approval. |
The Administrative team noted the following points: |
* The logic behind developing a document management system specific to large |
documents is that they basically do not have a life cycle to manage; they are stored |
indefinitely and have special needs and different parameters than a standard imaging |
and document management system for all city-wide documents. |
* The main objective of a large document management system is to provide |
accessibility to the most current copy of site plans, etc. as well as provide an indexing |
system that allows for searchability. |
* An issue with pursuing a future city-wide document management system hinges upon |
a retention schedule that is being handled in the Clerk's Office. |
* A large document management system could stand alone and could become a part of |
a city-wide document management system in the future. |
* The first step in developing any type of document management system is to compile |
an inventory of documents and assign a life cycle or retention schedule to them. |
Upon Committee discussion, the consensus was to redirect the Administrative team's |
efforts toward a city-wide document management system versus a system that |
encompasses just large documents due to the concern that the project will exceed the |
budgeted amount of $200,000 and will only encompass access, storage and retrieval of |
large cumbersome documents used by the certain departments at City Hall. |
A motion was made by Hill, seconded by Dalton, that this matter be |
Recommended for Approval to the Clerk's Office. |
Resolved that the Administration & Information Services (AIS) Committee |
recommends that the City's administrative staff re-direct their efforts toward a |
city-wide document management system versus a large format digital storage |
and retrieval system. |
The motion carried by the following vote: |
Aye:
Hill, Dalton, Holder and Kirksey
Absent:
Verschueren
2005-0462
Discuss Asset Management System
Asset Mgmt CIP Info.pdf
Mr. Bob Grace, Director of MIS, gave an brief recap status of the asset management |
project and included the following: |
* The Department of Public Service (DPS) began discussing asset management a |
couple of years ago during the budget process. It is a way for them to track their |
infrastructure and maintenance, etc. |
* An asset management system can also facilitate complaints, track performance |
bonds, and warranties, etc. |
* There was a lot of "due diligence" performed by the Administrative team in gathering |
information, hiring a consultant to performing a needs analysis to determine the needs, |
etc. |
The asset management project is planned for discussion in the 2006 budget process. |
Discussed
Mr. Kirksey exited at 5:35 PM. |
ROLL CALL
Melinda Hill, John Dalton and Barbara Holder
Present:
Gerard Verschueren and Stephen Kirksey
Absent:
Non-Voting Members Present: Bob Grace, Pam Lee, Jane Leslie, April Feng and |
Jennifer Stein |
Non-Voting Members Absent: None |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
2005-0243
Salary Recommendation for Directors' General Adjustment Recommendation - |
2006 |
Agenda Summary.pdf; AIS Agenda Summary.pdf; AIS Resolution |
options.pdf; Memo Galeczka re Directors General Adjustment.pdf; 060105 |
Revised Memo Lee.pdf; Revised Mayor_CM_Council Pay 6_05.pdf; |
Revised Wage Adjustmt Chart.pdf; Wage Adjustmt Chart.pdf; Revise |
Ms. Pam Lee, Human Resources Director, gave a brief update noting that she spoke |
with the City Attorney but did not request a written opinion regarding the |
recommendation for the Directors salary adjustments. She noted the following points: |
* The attorney indicated that since it is the responsibility of the AIS Committee to |
provide for Directors, Mayor and Boards & Commissions' Salaries that it was not |
necessary that specific salary adjustment decisions be made and that the Committee |
could vote to delay the salary adjustment decision as long as the salaries were included |
in the budget. |
* The salary survey data [electronically attached to file 2005-0243] has been updated to |
include wage adjustments from other municipalities through 2006 which shows that for |
the past two (2) to three (3) years, wage adjustments have ranged from two percent |
(2%) to three percent (3%). |
* The City has received Local 2491's proposal for salary adjustments for 2005, 2006 |
and 2007 which came in at a five percent (5%) adjustment for each year. The proposal |
is being negotiated. |
The Committee consensus was to recommend that Council delay making Directors |
salary adjustment recommendations until the contract negotiations are settled. |
However, the Committee will discuss the matter further at the June AIS meeting. |
Discussed
2005-0244
Salary Recommendation for City Council - 2006
Agenda Summary.pdf; AIS Agenda Summary.pdf; Memo Galeczka re CC |
Salary.pdf; AIS Resolution Options.pdf; Revised Mayor_CM_Council Pay |
6_05.pdf; Revised Mayor & CC 2005 Market Survey.pdf; Mayor & CC |
2005 Market Survey.pdf; Memo Lee HR 033105 .pdf; 0244 Reso |
The Committee briefly discussed Council's base salary and per diem fee for which |
Council is paid additional meetings. They discussed reducing the number of extra paid |
meetings from 32 to 28, however, the consensus was to discuss it further at the June |
AIS meeting. |
Discussed
Enactment No: RES0190-2005 |
2005-0245
Salary Recommendation for Mayor - 2006
Agenda Summary.pdf; AIS Agenda Summary.pdf; AIS Resolution |
Options.pdf; Memo Galeczka re Mayor's Salary.pdf; Revised |
Mayor_CM_Council Pay 6_05.pdf; Revised Mayor Council 2005 Market |
Survey.pdf; Mayor & CC Survey.pdf; Memo Lee HR 033105 .pdf; 0245 |
Resoluti |
The Committee briefly discussed the Mayor's salary, however, the consensus was to |
discuss it further at the June AIS meeting. |
Discussed
Enactment No: RES0192-2005 |
NEW BUSINESS
2005-0345
City Council Timesheets
The Committee consensus was to discuss this matter further at the June AIS meeting.
Discussed
2005-0346
City Council Internet Access
Internet Usage Memo.pdf; Administrative Policy #300_2004.pdf; 120199 |
Letter Staran.pdf; 110303 Letter Staran.pdf; 051404 Letter Staran.pdf; |
051502 Memo MIS.pdf |
Ms. Hill pointed out that the Clerk's office did a telephone survey to four (4) other |
municipalities regarding Internet access for council members and shared her concern |
with liabilities issues. After the Committee briefly discussed various issues, Mr. Dalton |
suggested that he and Ms. Hill draft a policy for review. The Committee consensus was |
to discuss this matter at the June AIS meeting. |
Discussed
YOUTH COMMENTS
None.
Ms. Feng exited at 6:00 PM |
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
None.
NEXT MEETING DATE
Tuesday, June 7, 2005 - 4:00 PM.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to discuss, Chairperson Holder adjourned the meeting |
at 6:17 PM. |
Minutes were prepared by Denise Mertz. |
Minutes were approved as presented at the August 2, 2005 Regular Administration & |
Information Services Committee Meeting. |